2000-2009 BEST OFs: Celebrity and Academic Style

It’s that time of year: Finals, Incessant Grading, avoiding shopping centers, seeking out limited edition Mint M&Ms, battling snow, or, if you’re in Austin, near-80 degrees and running in your shorts and a tank-top. But it’s also Listing Season, not only for the year, but the decade. While 2000 saw me just finishing my freshman year of college, it was also the beginning of my media studies career. The breadth of my memory during those years was impinged by the fact that Whitman (and my hometown in Idaho) are both surrounded by wheatfields and boasted very few screens, but as I moved through the Northwest (Wyoming, Seattle, Eugene) and down to Texas, I was exposed to the wider cultural world. (Did you know that some theaters play movies with SUBTITLES?!?) There was Netflix. There were iTunes. When I tried to watch Y Tu Mama Tambien, the clerk didn’t say “So, for Tuesday, I’ve got WHY TOO Mama Tambeen.”

These Best-Ofs are all over the map, but I hope you add your own thoughts to at least one of the categories below.

CELEBRITY

  • OVERALL CHAMPIONS OF THE CELEBRITY GAME

3.) Barack and Michelle Obama

2.) Ellen DeGeneres and Portia Di Rossi

1.) Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie

  • MOST INGENIOUS MANIPULATION OF THE MEDIASCAPE:

3.) Dudes behind “Shit My Dad Says” and “Stuff White People Like”

2.) Lonely Island Crew and Friends (Samberg and Timberlake in particular)

1.) Lady Gaga

Lady Gaga's Remarkable Exploding Breasts


  • MOST TRANSPARENT MANIPULATION OF CELEBRITY STATUS

3.) Octo-Mom

2.) Paula Abdul

1.) Heidi and Spencer

Speidi Dons Swine Flu Masks - BRILLIANT.


  • MOST BEIGE CELEBRITY PLAYERS, NO MATTER HOW HARD THEY TRY

3.) Eva Longoria

2.) Jessica Biels

1.5) Jessica Alba

1.) Katie Holmes

Jessica Alba thought having a baby would make her interesting. She was wrong.

  • BIG STAR LEAST LIKELY TO INSPIRE SCHOLARSHIP IN 30 YEARS

3.) Jennifer Garner

2.5) Matt Damon

2.) Vince Vaughn

1.) Jennifer Aniston

Hi, I'm Jennifer Aniston, and I'm bereft of ideological significance.

  • POOREST-PLAYED SCANDALS

3.) Jude Law

2.) Sarah Palin

1.5) Tom Cruise, immediately after couchjumping

1.) Tiger Woods

  • MOST LONGEVITY, DESPITE LACK OF PERTINENT PRODUCT:

3.) Trista and Ryan (From The Bachelorette)

2.) Britney Spears

1.) Nicole Richie

All I need is a cute baby and baggy clothes to keep you interested

  • MOST LIKELY TO DISPROVE THE CELEBRITY BABY THEORY:

3.) Shiloh Jolie-Pitt

2.) Tom Brady and Gisele Bunchen’s recently born super-child.

1.) Nahla Aubrey (Halle Berry + Gabriel Aubry)

CELEBRITY SUPER RACE

  • IRRECOVERABLY PLAYED OUT

3.) Jennifer Love Hewitt

2.) Tara Reid

1.) Lindsay Lohan

  • SADDEST SMUT:

3.) Owen Wilson

2.) Rihanna

1.) Britney

  • MOST ENTERTAINING CELEBRITY TWITTERERS:

3.) Shaq (Wins for his description alone: “VERY QUOTATIOUS, I PERFORM RANDOM ACTS OF SHAQNESS”

2.) Sarah Silverman

1.) Rainn Wilson


  • LEAST LIKELY TO TRANSITION FROM REALITY STARDOM TO ACTUAL STARDOM:

3.) Jon and Kate

2.) That Guy Who Actually Won American Idol Last Year (not Adam Lambert)

1.) Jersey Shore’s “The Situation”

The Situation's "Situation"

  • NICELY PLAYED, INDEED:

3.) K-Fed arranges to be paid thousands of dollars in weekly allowance so that he can watch his two sons, take them to amusement parks, tag along on ex-wife’s international tour, and gain 100 pounds.

2.) Reese Witherspoon sticks with asshole Ryan Phillippe just long enough to win her Oscar for Walk the Line; ends up with hottie Jakey G.

1.) Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie proclaim they’ll get married “when everyone else who wants to can.”


  • BIGGEST GAME CHANGERS:

3.5) Janice Min

3.) Perez Hilton

2.) X17

1.) TMZ.com

The 21st Century Gossip Maven

  • MOST INDELIBLE CELEBRITY IMAGES OF THE DECADE


MOVIES

  • FILMS VIEWED IN THEATER THAT SEEMED SUPER PROFOUND AT THE TIME BUT NOW MAKE ME SLIGHTLY EMBARRASSED:
  • 3.) Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King
    2.) American Beauty
    1.) Garden State

  • FILMS ATTENDED ALL ALONE THAT ATTRACTED THE MOST CONFUSED LOOKS FROM COUPLES AND GAGGLES OF WOMEN:

3.) Fighting

2.) The Notebook

1.) American Pie 2 (This was when I was working in the mountains of Wyoming and had a Sunday afternoon off. This was all the theater was playing. I missed movies. A lot.)

  • BEST QUIETEST FILMS:

3.) The Visitor

2.) Marie Antoinette

1.) Junebug

  • MOVIES VIEWED DURING FIRST FEW MONTHS IN FRANCE BEFORE MY FRENCH COULD HANDLE NO SUBTITLES AND THUS TOTALLY SCREWED WITH ME:

3.) Swordfish

2.) Muholland Drive (Watched twice more in English and still don’t fully comprehend.)

1.) La Pianiste (No, I’m not talking about Polanski’s Adrien Brody lovefest. I’m talking Haneke’s brutal masochistic self-mutilation film from 2001.)

  • MOVIES ON WHICH I WROTE MY UNDERGRADUATE HONORS THESIS, WHICH TOTALLY SUCKS, BUT TURNS OUT THESE MOVIES AGE QUITE WELL:

3.) In the Bedroom

2.) You Can Count On Me

1.) The Royal Tenenbaums


  • MOVIES THAT MADE ME GET ON BOARD WITH A CULTURAL PHENOMENON I HAD THERETOFORE REJECTED:

3.) Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring

2.) Ratatouille

1.) Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban


  • MOVIES THAT TOTALLY F-ING TOOK ADVANTAGE OF ME AND CAUSED ME TO WEEP UNCONTROLLABLY FOR 1/3 OF THE FILM’S LENGTH:

3.) Brokeback Mountain

2.) The Notebook

1.5) The Diving Bell and the Butterfly

1.) The New World

  • FILMS THAT MADE ME CHAMPION AUTEURISM EVEN THOUGH I KNOW BETTER:

3.) Children of Men (Cuaron)

2.5) Cold Mountain (Mingella)

2.) Brokeback Mountain (Lee)

1.5) Bright Star (Campion)

1.) The New World (Malick)

  • MOVIES I REALLY LOVED THAT I USE AS PROOF THAT I’M NOT EUROCENTRIC

3.) Nobody Knows

2.) The Return

1.) Spring, Summer, Winter, Fall…and Spring


  • FAVORITE FOREIGN FILMS THAT PROVE THAT I AM INDEED EUROCENTRIC

3.) Bloody Sunday

2.5) Read My Lips

2.) Happy-Go-Lucky

1.5) The Wind that Shakes the Barley

1.) The Lives of Others and Let the Right One In


  • TOP NATURE PORN

3.) The Assassination of Jesse James

2.) The New World

1.) Old Joy


  • MOVIES THAT ARE INDEED AWESOME BUT MY STUDENTS’ MASTERBATORY ENTHUSIASM HAS RATHER SPOILED THEM:

3.) City of God

2.) Kill Bill / Inglourious Basterds

1.) Batman Begins


  • BEST MAINSTREAM, TIGHTLY PLOTTED, TOTALLY CLASSIC HOLLYWOOD CINEMA BUT OVERWHELMINGLY ENTERTAINING:

3.) Star Trek

2.5) 3:10 to Yuma

2.) The Departed

1.5) Inside Man

1.) Almost Famous


  • BEST DOCUMENTARIES INVOLVING HANDSOME FRENCHMAN IN ALTERNATIVE CLASSROOM SETTINGS:

2.) To Be and To Have (Etre and Avoir)

1.) The Class (La Classe)


  • BEST UNTOUTED MASTERPIECES:

3.) Michael Clayton

2.) In Bruges

1.) The Brothers Bloom

  • BEAUTIFUL THINGS WITH NO LIST HOME:

The Fantastic Mr. Fox, Amelie, Where the Wild Things Are, Wall-E, A Serious Man, Frozen River, Wendy and Lucy, There Will Be Blood, Half Nelson, United 93, A History of Violence, The Squid and the Whale, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Synechdoche NY, American Splendor, 25th Hour, Frida, About a Boy, Adaptation, The Believer, Memento, Gosford Park, Moulin Rouge.


  • AND ANNIE’S RATHER ARBITRARY, FORGETFUL, AND WILLFULLY EMOTIONAL TOP FILMS OF 2000-2009:

10.) Brokeback Mountain

9.) The Hurt Locker

7.) Up

6.) We Are England

5.) No Country for Old Men

4.) Four Months, Three Weeks, Two Days

3.) The Best of Youth

2.) Children of Men

TIED FOR FIRST: Pan’s Labyrinth / Junebug / The New World / The Diving Bell and the Butterfly


10 Responses to “2000-2009 BEST OFs: Celebrity and Academic Style”

  1. Carolina says:

    This needs more Mean Girls.

    But I am super happy to see Etre et Avoir on here, and La Pianiste is great, though I can’t even imagine watching that without subtitles for the first time. Crazy.

  2. Colin Tait says:

    I disagree with you about Matt Damon, whose name will be endlessly repeated whenever people watch Team America: World Police, and whose lime green speedo will gain prestige as people realize what a good movie The Talented Mr. Ripley really was.

  3. Katie says:

    LOVED Amelie so much. And Happy-Go-Lucky is unbelievable underrated, Sally Hawkins was ROBBED for both an Oscar nom and a BAFTA nom. The Clint Eastwood backed “I WANT MY OSCAR!! WHERE’S MY OSCAR” Jolie in “The Changeling” stole those spots. Yes, stole. Die B*tch.

  4. Christine Pobke says:

    Friggin’ awesome list Annie!!! :) Totally agree with practically every listed item, with the exception of the films I’ve never heard of (Best of Youth/The Hurt Locker/Old Joy/The Visitor/Read my lips, to name a few… And to think i thought I was a film buff!).

  5. princesscowboy says:

    Brokeback Mountain is one of the most perfect films ever made. EVER. I curse the people who turned “I wish I could quit you” into a punchline. And I am STILL mad about that Oscar race. Effing CRASH.

    I also agree with AMELIE’s presence on your best list. Lots of folks see it as middlebrow tripe but it is so darn charming. Love it.

  6. sunny says:

    Just before Oscar season Tom O’neil started the campaign against Jolie. ‘she will be nominated because it’s Eastwood movie.’ Then he put her name at the 5th of best actress list. The funny thing was he removed her name when he saw some critics were writing what Katie wrote in above comment. Mission accomplished. He replaced Jolie with Cate Blanchett. Retrospect it was Kate who did everything and second was Anne Hathaway. These two got FULL support from CAA. CAA had to decide whom they would focus on and it was Kate, Meryl, Ann. Jolie got bunch of nominations for A Mighty Heart(2007) as well as Challenging did but failed Oscar nomination. Why ? Because Academy voters didn’t see that indie small movie. I like Sally Howkins. She was brilliant in Happy Go Lucky. It was said that old male Academy voters didn’t see her movie.

  7. Chuck says:

    Great lists. And, yeah, Crash over Brokeback Mountain? That’s one for the ages, kind of like Rocky beating out Taxi Driver. Except maybe worse.

  8. filmdr says:

    Very funny. Your assessment of the “most beige celebrities” seems harsh, if also accurate. I dislike thinking Lindsay Lohan is “irretrievably played out.” Also, I need to rewatch The Royal Tenenbaums.

  9. [...] indie broke. For one, I’m not a huge fan of many of these movies (I’m with Annie — Garden State seemed way less profound the second time I watched it). For another, to my [...]

  10. Claire says:

    Great lists! I just ran across your blog after Googling “celebrity and academia.” Good stuff. :)